239 Comments
User's avatar
matt's avatar

Originalism literally drives me into a blind rage - the justices piously claim to be it, right up until they need a conservative policy outcome, and then they just make shit up (major questions doctrine, qualified immunity).

Expand full comment
Abigail Welborn's avatar

Blind rage is such an apt description. Republicans cause a problem, blame it on the Dems, and then promise to fix it. WHY do people keep falling for it?!

Expand full comment
Jen the Historian's avatar

Lawless

Also, I love this essay. It breaks down a lot of big things into manageable parts. I'm a court watcher (and a historian) but I get that it's overwhelming/ignorable for most people because it can be a. lot.

Expand full comment
Jo Piazza's avatar

You're the winner. Email me your mailing address at jo.piazza@gmail.com

Expand full comment
Jen the Historian's avatar

Woohoo! Will do. Thanks!!

Expand full comment
Betsy's avatar

Can you recommend anyone to follow for someone new to watching the courts? I’m starting to get more engaged with them as I anxiously await the opinion due soon on United States vs. Skrmetti. I follow local and national organizations that keep me updated about LBGTQ legislation because that will impact my family directly. I’d like to expand into watching other important issues.

Expand full comment
Sarah's avatar

I highly recommend Leah Litman’s podcast that she co-hosts with two colleagues called Strict Scrutiny. They discuss recent Supreme Court decisions and themes, it’s a great place to start!

Expand full comment
Lisa R's avatar

Steve Vladeck has a wonderful Substack One First. Highly recommend.

Expand full comment
Becca's avatar

The Amicus Podcast with Dahlia Lithwick (from Slate) is also really good.

Expand full comment
Deborah - NC's avatar

Just put a hold on Lawless from my library. My book group's raison d'être is 'reading to understand' and the book for June is Love Wins - Lawless will be a great companion read.

Expand full comment
Brianna's avatar

LAWLESS!

Currently listening to “The Originalism Trap” and love how this post complements what I’m learning there!

Expand full comment
Jo Piazza's avatar

You're the winner. Email me your mailing address at jo.piazza@gmail.com

Expand full comment
Allyson's avatar

Lawless. Great article and thank you for the book recommendation.

Expand full comment
Kyla's avatar

Lawless! This book sounds fascinating, although I'm sure I will be gnashing my teeth the whole time.

Expand full comment
Madeline Chimento's avatar

Lawless (I might have missed this 😆)

Expand full comment
Jo Piazza's avatar

You're the winner. Email me your mailing address at jo.piazza@gmail.com

Expand full comment
Nadine F.'s avatar

LAWLESS

Keep these powerful & insightful articles coming! I SO value all that you are sharing! My mind & heart are a sponge...

Expand full comment
Jo Piazza's avatar

You're the winner. Email me your mailing address at jo.piazza@gmail.com

Expand full comment
Laurie's avatar

Lawless

This situation is terrifying and I appreciate this summary!

Expand full comment
Jo Piazza's avatar

You're the winner. Email me your mailing address at jo.piazza@gmail.com

Expand full comment
Karen Bernhardt's avatar

Let's work LAWLESS in our favor!

Expand full comment
Hallie LeBlanc's avatar

LAWLESS

Expand full comment
Lena Risler's avatar

Lawless

Expand full comment
Julie's avatar

Lawless

Expand full comment
Kristen H's avatar

Lawless

Expand full comment
Jenna's avatar

Lawless

Expand full comment
lauren dye's avatar

LAWLESS

Expand full comment
Jan Wash's avatar

Lawless

Expand full comment